New European Commission Marred By Corporate Conflicts of Interest


The newly elected president of the European Commission and his cabinet - who together form the central executive body for the 28 member states of the European Union - have deep ties with powerful corporate interests that make them poor choices to support citizen rights, say critics.

The European Commission oversees a European Union budget of €142 billion a year and over 23,000 staff. The Commission functions plays a key role in proposing and implementing pan European legislation which directly affect its 507 million citizens as well as rules that govern the national budgets of the 28 member states.

Jean-Claude Juncker who elected by the European Parliament to take over as European Commission president on November 1 came to the job after eight years as minister of Luxembourg, where he helped transform the country into the largest tax haven on the continent.

"Juncker has dedicated his career to ensuring that society becomes less fair; that wealthy institutions and individuals can avoid the taxes little people and small businesses must pay," writes Nick Cohen, a columnist for the Guardian.

Indeed the European Commission that Juncker has taken over is currently investigating tax arrangements for two major multinationals in Luxembourg - a deal with Amazon from the U.S. struck in 2003 and another with Fiat of Italy that was agreed in 2012.

"National authorities must not allow selected companies to understate their taxable profits by using favourable calculation methods," said Joaquín Almunia, the European Commission vice president in charge of competition policy, in a press statement issued one week before Juncker took the helm in Brussels. "It is only fair that subsidiaries of multinational companies pay their share of taxes and do not receive preferential treatment which could amount to hidden subsidies."

Juncker will be joined by 27 other commissioners, one from each member state, who were elected October 22 after four weeks of hearings, that activists say were deeply flawed. "Commissioners were not adequately grilled about their background and possible conflicts of interest and thus if they were suitable for the role," says Olivier Hoedeman of Corporate Europe Observatory, a Brussels based research and campaign group.* "Too often they failed to elicit precise answers, letting the commissioners-designate off-the-hook."

Corporate Europe Observatory singled out several who they believe are ill suited for their new roles including Miguel Arias Cañete of Spain, the new climate commissioner; Jonathan Hill of the UK, in charge of financial services; Carlos Moedas of Portugal, the research commissioner; and Karmenu Vella of Malta, who will take on environment, fisheries and maritime affairs.

For example Cañete, the new Energy and Climate Change commissioner, is a shareholder and former president of two Spanish oil companies: Petrolífera Dúcar SL and Petrologis Canaris SL. "Given his current and recent ties to the oil industry, he would regularly find himself caught in real or perceived conflicts of interest," writes Fabian Flues of Friends of the Earth Europe. (Cañete was elected despite the fact that almost 600,000 people signed a petition to oppose his appointment.)

Hill from the UK, the new Financial Services and Capital Markets Union commissioner, founded a public relations and lobbying company called Quiller Consultants that has typically represented financial businesses like Bank of America and HSBC and investment managers like Brewin Dolphin and Citadel. Oliver Wright of the Independent called Hill the "most senior former lobbyist in Government" when he became Speaker of the House of Lords.

"European citizens who care about the environment, about tackling the banks, about de-intensifying agriculture, should all be concerned about the composition and direction of the Juncker Commission," adds Hoedeman. "It will continue, and possibly expand, the pressure on social rights and public services, including under the slogan of 'competitiveness', as advocated strongly by the biggest and most powerful corporate lobby groups."

* Pratap Chatterjee is a member of the advisory board of Corporate Europe Observatory.

AMP Section Name:Regulation
  • 106 Money & Politics
* indicates required