Ecuador's Yasuni Park: Oil Exploration or Nature Protection?
Manuela Omari Ima, a Waorani woman from the Ecuadorian Amazon, was
born in the Yasuni National Park, a 2.5 million acre primary tropical
rainforest at the intersection of the Andes, the Amazon and the
Equator. That intersection is also the heart of a struggle between two
plans: one for oil exploration and another that would permanently
protect one of the most biologically diverse regions of the planet.
The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) declared Yasuni a biosphere reserve in 1989, after biologists found that a mere 2.5 acres of this forest contained as many tree species as in the United States and Canada combined. It is also home to jaguars, woolly and
spider monkeys, and harpy eagles -- the most powerful bird of prey in the
world. Some of the species in Yasuni, however, live on the brink of
extinction: including more than 20 globally threatened mammal species such as
the white-bellied spider monkey and the rare golden-mantled tamarin.
The animals, birds and plants are not the only species whose numbers
are shrinking rapidly. At the time of her birth, Omari Ima, who is now in her mid-thirties and is chair of Amwae, the Waorani women's organization, says that there were some 16,000 Waorani. "Today, there are no more than about a thousand of us left," says
Omari Ima. "It is, simply, a struggle for survival."
One of the key reasons for this, she says, was the arrival of multinational oil companies in the latter part of the 20th century, which represented her tribe's first and forced contact with industrial civilization. Soon displaced to a controlled existence in a reservation, Omari Ima's family and tribe was divided, just as the rainforest itself soon became divided by roads and oil fields.
A new plan, yet to be funded, could bring a halt to this exploration,
but some damage has already been done.
Petrobras Wins Yasuni Contract
Yasuni sprawls over two countries -- Ecuador and Peru -- both of whom
see the Amazon as a potentially lucrative source of income. In August
2004, when Brazilian president Lula da Silva came on a state visit,
the Ecuadorian government granted an environmental license for
Petrobras, the Brazilian state-owned corporation, to drill for oil in
Block 31. Also known as the Ishpingo Tambococha Tiputini
(ITT) oilfields, ITT is believed to hold up to a billion barrels of
oil, almost a quarter of the country's total known reserves. At
today's oil prices, this could mean revenue of over $700 million a
year. (The Peruvian government has just approved environmental impact
studies for two areas -- known as Blocks 67 and 39, that have been
acquired by U.S.-based Barrett Resources and Repsol of Spain.)
|Explosion in Bolivia
One evening in June 2005, 45-year old Emilio Uceida and his two
sons were out on a fishing trip by the river next to their home in
Chapare-SurubÃ, in the Bolivian Amazon. The area is being explored
for oil and gas by Repsol-YPF, a Spanish company, which has
contracted with Skanska to oversee technical matters. A spark from a
cigarette lighter used by one of the men in the boat caused gas that
had drifted over the river from an exploration site to ignite, causing
the father and his sons to catch fire.
burns that he remains in hospital care to this date. His condition is
critical and doctors say that he will remain an invalid for the rest
of his life.
authorities and organizations from the Cochabamba province later
visited the area to inspect the oil field, they were denied access to
the exploration sites.
Uceida family for "sabotage," which has scared Emilio
Armed with these new contracts from Quito, Ecuador's capital, the
companies have attempted to win over the people of the forest. Alicia
Cahuiya, another Waorani woman who lives in the town of Pujo, says the
companies offered the indigenous villagers items such as soccer
clothes and candy in return for permission to drill for oil on their
"The companies have often bought villagers off with small gifts,
because the villagers have not understood what was going on when the
company representatives came calling," she says. "Later,
when people have become sick from contamination caused by the oil
extraction and begun to protest, the military have rushed in to
support the companies."
With the tacit permission of the villagers, Petrobras started to
set up the infrastructure for oil exploration on the outer edges of
Yasuni, such as the construction of a harbor along the edge of the Napo
River in March of 2005. They hired a Swedish construction company
named Skanska, which has numerous similar contracts in the region such
as in Brazil and Bolivia, to do the work. Skanska currently works in Ecuador with Tecpecuador and Petrobras in Block 18, and in Bolivia it continues to do controversial work with Repsol.
Local authorities soon started to complain about Skanska's work in the area. Environmental inspector Marcos BaÃ±os, head of the
environmental authority for the Amazonian province of Orellana, says
that Skanska behaved in a suspicious manner. BaÃ±os says that company
representatives have visited the authority to offer to perform
"projects." "I considered it extortion," says BaÃ±os.
And Raul Vega, an official in the provincial environmental office in
the oil town of Coca, says that the company refused to cooperate with
them. "The Skanska boss Oswaldo Contreras was the first Skanska
person we contacted," Vega explains, "and he refused to give
us the information we required. If they had only shown us they'd done
an environmental study, we would have given them a permit, but it was
not until a subsequent occasion that Skanska submitted any information. That information, however, turned out to be false. The
company claimed it had conducted an environmental study, which was a
complete and utter lie."
The construction was halted after a few months. Petrobras' permit
was revoked and the company was asked to conduct an environmental
Skanska and Petrobras' joint operations were also sharply criticized by environmental groups and local communities in Ecuador
for the initial exploration work conducted in 2005.
AcciÃ³n EcolÃ³gica, a Quito-based environmental group that opposes
oil exploration in the Amazon, says that they conducted an
on-the-ground inspection in Chiru Isla, a Quichua indigenous village inside Yasuni and along the Napo river. The inspection revealed that five families out of 20 experienced poisoning due to dumped diesel and
oil in the watercourse from where the villagers got their drinking
water. All the members of these families became seriously ill,
suffering from headaches and vomiting.
The investigation by AcciÃ³n EcolÃ³gica also revealed that waste from
latrines on Skanska's construction site had been dumped in the
surrounding water courses. This is in violation of Ecuador's health laws,
and causes a major hazard for the local population.
The Chiru Isla villagers, who fear repression and therefore prefer to
remain anonymous, also say that Skanska hired people from the local
population to perform dangerous jobs, like carrying heavy equipment
and climbing at the construction site without protection -- but never
paid them. Skanska is also accused of having purchased food supplies
like bananas and yucca in the villages, but failing to pay.
The company disagrees. One of Skanska's regional managers in the
Amazon basin is Milton Diaz, an Argentinian oil exploration veteran
who has worked in the industry for many decades. He dismisses the
complaints: "People here in the bush should be grateful to
industry instead of just complaining and making unreasonable demands,"
Diaz also says that the indigenous people are a threat to Skanska.
"People here are slightly backward. You never know when the
barbarians are going to start shooting arrows from the bushes. At
Skanska, we also have a strict security culture. Personally, I never
go unarmed in the bush."
The Skanska engineeers pay for armed private security guards, but the
company also has an agreement with the military for support under a
special security council set up by the government of Ecuador in
January 2006 called GESPETRO - Grupo Especial de Seguridad Petrolera
(Special Group on Oil Security). GESPETRO is charged with coordinating
security for the companies involved with oil extraction such as Petrobras.
The contracts include stipulations that the oil companies are to
supply the military with infrastructure, food, fuel, living quarters
and emergency medical care in exchange for protection. Similarly, the
companies are obligated under the contracts to inform the Napo
military base of community projects and programs that the company
provides to the civilian population.
Alicia Cahuiya says that effectively the land belonging to her people
in Yasuni has now been occupied by the companies' oil fields and the
military: "Every step we take is watched, and if we voice a
protest, Repsol turns the military on us," she says. "If we
do not comply, they threaten or beat us. There have even been cases where the military have killed Waorani people and thrown the bodies in
Attorney Bolivar Beltran, from FundaciÃ³n Lianas, says that the
contract violates Chapter V of Ecuador's constitution, as well as the
UN Convention on the Rights of Indigenous and Tribal People. Both assure indigenous peoples a set of cultural and self-determination rights, such as the right to be part of all decision-making on issues concerning their lands.
Pablo Fajardo, a lawyer for the Ecuadorian network Frente de
Defensa de la Amazonia (FDA), says that this is standard practice.
"The population is being exposed to serious health hazards and
illness related to oil spills and deliberate waste dumping while they
often live in fear of the companies, whose power is expressed through
threats and violence," he says. "By using armed private forces, the companies try to control and stifle local resistance at any price.
This is what it's like in the entire region, and all companies working
with oil are forced to deal with this reality."
Back in Sweden, Noel Morrin, Skanska's sustainability manager at the company headquarters in Stockholm, claims that the company is not breaking laws or violating its own ethical code of conduct.
But some Skanska officials say that they are concerned about the
allegations in Ecuador. Peter Gimbe, the senior vice president for
communications in Stockholm, says that headquarters has little insight
into local conditions and that they are investigating the complaints.
An Uncertain Future
Today the future of the ITT fields remain uncertain. The new
government of Rafael Correa initially considered the possibility of
creating a consortium with Ecuadorean state-owned oil companies to
develop the ITT fields. Venezuela's state oil firm PDVSA and
Argentina's Enarsa expressed interest in taking part in any future consortium.
In May 2007 Correa put forward an innovative idea: his government
would refrain from exploiting Yasuni in exchange for receiving at
least $350 million annually from the international community. The idea
was promoted heavily by the government, with vice-president Lenin Moreno Garces staging an event during the Live Earth concert last
year. TV cameras broadcast him joining nearly 100 people to spell out the words "Live Yasuni" from a forest clearing.
Organizations like the Wallace Global Fund have committed $100,000 to
the initiative. A number of other groups including AcciÃ³n
EcolÃ³gica, Amazon Watch, Earth Economics, University of Maryland, Charles Stewart Mott Foundation, Pachamama Alliance, and World Resources Institute,
have put their weight behind it as well, but the plan has yet to get firm
commitments for the full sum of money.
Editor's Note: CorpWatch is a recipient of funding from the Wallace
Global Fund. This article was commissioned without any input from the
- 23 Private Security
- 107 Energy
- 116 Human Rights
- 182 Health
- 183 Environment
- 185 Corruption
- 208 Regulation