Contact l Sitemap

home industries issues reasearch weblog press

Home  » Industries » Pharmaceuticals

South Africa: Indigenous Group Wins Rights to its Healing Herbs

by Mercedes SayaguesInter Press Service
March 28th, 2003

ANDRIESVALE -- In a victory for indigenous groups, a landmark profit-sharing agreement has been signed providing credit and compensation to one of South Africa's oldest groups with extensive traditional knowledge of healing plants and herbs.

The South African San Council and the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) of South Africa signed an agreement that recognizes and rewards the San people as holders of traditional knowledge.

At a simple but moving ceremony in Andriesvale, a remote corner of the Kalahari, the San nation won the rights to benefit from their traditional knowledge of plants and herbs -- including a plant known to suppress hunger.

The San will get up to eight percent of profits from a diet drug derived from the Hoodia, a plant they know well. For thousands of years, the San -- the oldest people in southern Africa -- have chewed the bitter Hoodia twice a day to suppress hunger and thirst during long hunting trips.

"Our ancestors taught us to survive by being attentive to the land, rain, game and plants," says Kxao Moses, a Namibian San and chair of the Working Group of Indigenous Minorities in Southern Africa. Even today the San treat hunger, fever, eye allergies and stomach pain with the Hoodia.

In 1996, scientists from the parastatal CSIR isolated the Hoodia's hunger-suppressing chemical component, or P57, and patented it.

In 1997, CSIR licensed the UK-based firm Phytopharm to further develop and commercialize P57. The following year, Phytopharm licensed drug giant Pfizer -- of Viagra fame -- to develop and market P57.

Throughout, CSIR retained the patent believed now to be worth billions of dollars. The market for a natural appetite-suppressant drug is huge. In the United States alone there are between 35-65 million clinically obese people. Worldwide, obesity is rising fast.

But the San, who had shared their knowledge with CSIR scientists, had been left out of the picture. To add insult to injury, in July 2001, a Pfizer spokesman discussing research on P57 mentioned the link to the San people but said the San were extinct.

The San peoples of southern Africa angrily complained. An international scandal ensued.

The South African San Council, set up in November 2001 and representing the Khomani, the !Xun and the Khwe, opened talks with the CSIR demanding recognition of their knowledge and a share of benefits.

The timing was right. Back in 1996, indigenous knowledge was an obscure issue and the CSIR an institution shaped by the apartheid regime it had served well for 40 years.

Five years later, protection of indigenous knowledge is debated at the World Trade Organization (WTO) and promoted by the post-apartheid CSIR.

It was a thorny issue at the 2002 Earth Summit in Johannesburg because indigenous knowledge systems clash with Western intellectual property rules (IPR). The latter view knowledge as the property of an individual or a company, while traditional knowledge is collectively owned and handed down through generations.

Under pressure from the developing world -- WTO is reviewing the IPR system. Buoyed by international agreements like the 2000 Cartagena Protocol on Biological Safety, an addenda to the 1992 Convention on Biological Diversity, countries in the South are passing laws to prevent biopiracy.

In 1999, the Organization of African Unity (OAU) approved an African Model Law that comprehensively covers IPR issues for biodiversity and indigenous knowledge. African countries must now pass domestic laws that comply with it. Few have done so.

The South African government is considering a draft bill that requires proof of prior informed consent of communities before granting patents for products or elements derived from their traditional knowledge.

The agreement between the San and the CSIR reinforces bioprospection as opposed to biopiracy.

"Big pharma can't do business as they did before. It's payback time," says Tom Suchanandan, an academic with the Council for Human Sciences Research of South Africa.

He points that "this is no hastily construed document but took lots of time and effort", one reason being the public scandal, another South Africa's legal vacuum on this matter.

"The CSIR and the San had to produce an agreement able to withstand international scrutiny and it does," says Minister of arts, culture, science and technology, Ben Ngubane.

For three years, the South Africa San Council negotiated with the CSIR on behalf of the San in Angola, Botswana, Namibia, Zambia and Zimbabwe. In a unique novel arrangement, the San will share profits across borders.

The CSIR will pay the San eight percent of milestone payments made by its licensee Phytopharm during the drug's clinical development over the next 3-4 years. If and when the drug is marketed, possibly in 2008, the San will get six percent of royalties.

"The CSIR, being owned by government, was rather embarrassed and we played that embarrassment hard," recalls human rights lawyer Roger Chennels, the San's legal counsel.

Already $32,000 (R259,066) has been paid. Milestone payments for the San could reach $1 million to $1.4 million while royalties could top $7.4 million annually during the 15-20 years before a patent expires, says Petro Terblanche, CSIR Biochemtek Director.

The San have greet need of the income. Residing in the region for 40,000 years, in the last 2,000 they have been dispossessed by several waves of newcomers. Today, commercial ranching, large-scale agriculture, even national parks threaten their hunter-gatherer lifestyle.

"The San's soft culture does not do well in a Western capitalist world," says Chennels.

For centuries their culture has been devalued as "uncivilized". Even their language is on the verge of extinction, squeezed out by Afrikaans and English. Less than two dozen elderly San speakers survive in South Africa. A handful was at Andriesvale to witness their leaders sign the agreement.

Ravaged by low self-esteem, poverty, alcoholism and unemployment, the San remain marginalised. Only recently a wave of interest is re-valuing San rock paintings and crafts, their harmony with nature, practices of heightened consciousness states and cultural beliefs.

"This (agreement) is about more than money, it's about our culture," says Tina, a trainee tracker at Molopo lodge in Andriesvale.

Asked about their needs, a group of young women quickly say "jobs and education in our language".

If the diet drug is produced, it is not yet clear whether the Hoodia will be grown commercially or the molecule laboratory-produced. "For South Africa's economy, it is preferable to farm it. For risk management, to use a reactive in a lab," says Terblanche.

Dreadlocked, decked in an opossum tail headdress, beads and a handmade leather medicine pouch, community leader Jan van der Westhuysen, 47, crouches and gingerly touches the prickly plant. "This is life to us, it gave us energy and sustenance," he says.

He looks around the dry savannah. Hoodia was plentiful here when he grew up but no longer, he says. "Humans are not taking good care of the world."





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.